By REBECCA CARR
rcarr@coxnews.com
Cox News Service
Wednesday, March 05, 2008WASHINGTON —
The Federal Aviation Administration lacks an
adequate system for checking the quality of
commercial airplane parts, creating a potential
safety risk for airline passengers, according to
a new oversight report.
"Neither manufacturers nor FAA inspectors have
provided effective oversight of suppliers; this
has allowed substandard parts to enter the
aviation supply chain," states a 24-page report
from the Transportation Department's inspector
general.
Federal investigators assessed the oversight of
suppliers to the nation's major aircraft
manufacturers-Boeing Co., Bombardier
Aerospace/Learjet Inc., General Electric
Aircraft Engines, Rolls-Royce PLC and Pratt &
Whitney and Airbus. They found "widespread
deficiencies" at all but one of 21 suppliers
that make parts for those companies.
The report found weaknesses throughout the FAA's
oversight system for manufacturers and their
suppliers. For example, the report blamed four
engine failures in 2003 on faulty speed sensors
on fuel pumps. The faulty parts were traced to
unapproved design changes made by a sub-tier
supplier, according to the report.
In another example, a supplier delivered 5,000
landing gear parts for large commercial aircraft
that were not made properly. At least one of
those gear parts failed while in service,
according to the report.
"While the FAA became aware of this in 2003, it
has not performed a supplier audit at the
facility in the last 4 years," according to the
report.
Investigators at another plant witnessed an
employee using a piece of paper, scotch-taped to
a work surface, to measure an oil and fuel
pressure transmitter.
"The aerospace manufacturers and the FAA have
put the flying public at unnecessary risk," said
Nick Schwellenbach, an investigator at the
nonprofit watchdog group Project on Government
Oversight, which released the report in advance
of the Transportation Department on Friday.
The FAA and the Aerospace Industries Association
dispute that the public is in any danger, citing
its low-fatality safety record.
The agency plans to implement a new quality
assurance program next year to pinpoint
potential risks in the supply chain, said Alison
Duquette, a spokesperson for the FAA.
The report suggested that part of the reason for
a lack of oversight stemmed from companies
outsourcing parts to foreign countries. Airline
parts that were once only made in America are
now built in Asia, Europe and South America.
The report said that the FAA needs to "improve
its risk-based oversight system as it does not
ensure that manufacturers regularly audit their
suppliers."
The FAA has inspected an average of 1 percent of
its suppliers used by the manufacturers reviewed
by the inspector general, the report found. At
the current rate, it would take inspectors
nearly 100 years to audit every supplier once.
"We recognize that it is a global industry and
there is a trend toward building products
globally, so we agree that we need closer
scrutiny and we need to find better ways to find
potential safety problems," Duquette said.
Michael C. Romanowski, vice president of civil
aviation at the Aerospace Industries
Association, said the association is reviewing
the report to see if there are areas where the
industry can improve.
"Manufacturers take their responsibilities for
safe products incredibly seriously," Romanowski
said. To ensure that manufacturers are
delivering safe products, the industry is
continuously looking for ways to improve the
quality of its products.
"We believe the systems in place provide a high
degree of protection of the public and that is
reflected in the safety record of the industry,"
Romanowski said. "Aviation is by far the safest
mode of travel and continuing to improve it
every day."
Aviation experts say that the lack of oversight
of airplane suppliers has been an issue since
the early 1990s. It is indicative of a larger
problem confronting the aviation industry.
"The whole deterioration of the FAA oversight
system is posing a long term risk to aviation
safety," said Jim Hall, former chairman of the
National Transportation Safety Board. "There are
dangerous trends in the aviation industry
because we are failing to adequately fund the
FAA."
The failure of the federal regulatory system to
adjust to the new outsourcing environment is
posing a danger to American companies of all
stripes, Hall said.
But a defective DVD is a small monetary loss
compared to a defective airplane part that could
cause a significant loss of life, Hall said.
The airline industry is evaluating the report.
"We are reviewing the inspector general's report
and plan further discussions with the FAA and
the manufacturers in order to fully understand
what steps have been and are being taken to
address any concerns," said Victoria Day,
managing director of communications for the Air
Transport Association, a trade group of
airlines.
And the manufacturers are looking for ways to
improve oversight of their suppliers .
Peter Conte, a spokesperson at Boeing, said the
company takes the inspector general's audit
seriously.
"We will work with the appropriate agencies to
ensure a full understanding of the report and,
if necessary, we will make changes to
ensure the highest level of safety for our
products," Conte said.
Rebecca Carr is a Washington correspondent for
Cox Nedwspapers.